Keeper: SM - Great flow, good speed. Deep enough to be a real challenge. Great music and I like that there are a couple of quotes for each shot, so they don't get annoying.
Surprise Keeper: Corvette. Fast and flowy with a short ball times and a simple rule set yet is challenging enough for me that I haven't been able to get to the wizard mode yet. Keeps me playing just one more game and usually the one I start up first.
Overated: TAF In its day it was groundbreaking. But now, there are just many more which are better IMO. If it was put out 10 years later I don't think it would have sold as many.