Quoted from MacGruber:It's gota be GNR. I got it just outside my top 300 but there are still many ppl (not as many as there used to be) that think it's the goat because of the "experience". TS4 lately but not for me that's just a price and liscencing issue. I don't think ppl hate the game.
You could make the case that just about every JJP game ties for the top spot based on some combination of factors - initial release, complicated code, lack of code updates, theme integration, theme in general, price, mechanical issues, playfield issues, callouts, and flipper feel. There hasn't been one homerun release yet that hasn't resulted in an ongoing Montague/Capulet war between the diehard fanboys and the unapologetic haters.