When I was a kid, every pin I came across was broken
If somebody had a game in their home, it was always just assumed that you shouldn't touch it because it doesn't work.
I never got to play Popeye. I've played most solid state pins ever created, but this one has alluded me.
It does seem like a game most diehard pinheads aren't thrilled with, but then they are all very picky & sometimes fail to factor in whether the game is just plain fun or not. Regardless of whether things are cluttered or bad rules or even poor design, if the game is a good time then that is half the battle right there.
With the prices they often go for, I'd always give thought to getting Popeye if one comes around, but the rub comes where I'd have to move out one of my current games that I definitely like in order to take a gamble. The solution, make more space appear somehow.