I think standing over the games, JJP's look better. They just pack stuff in and their light animations are so smooth. On initial play, Stern games grab you out the gate. However, I find that JJP games are better for the long haul. I've sold all but one of the Stern's I've owned but still have all my JJP's. I think it shows that JJP games really shine at home. Plus, when I have folks over, they always gravitate to the JJP games in my lineup. There is no denying how attractive that big LCD is. Not that many people say they love the Hobbit movies, but once people see the dragon animations on my game, they can't stop playing it. As far as buying used, I think used JJP's are better because they have less dimpling. Stern playfields look like someone who had horrible acne as a kid after about a month. As much as I'd love to pick up a used BM '66, I won't because of how bad the art looks under all those dimples. As far as quality, I think both are about the same. I have a Pirates and have no chipping issues. It's luck of the draw no matter which manufacturer you buy from. But, don't count out CGC or Spooky. They have great games, too. Look at Spooky if you want something more niche and unique.