Top 3 (I'd buy 'em):
Star Trek - looptastic, ramptastic, and space noises always a plus
POTC - love the treasure hunt/map/exploration/sinking ship aspects
Big Buck Hunter (whaaaat?!?) - yep... simple goals & plays like a classic shooting gallery
Middle 3 (I'd drop some quarters):
LOTR - many shots & lots of goals but a bit too easy and repetitive "X hundred souls" thing... also too much computery low-res artwork
Metallica - way cool hand-drawn art & solid but tough gameplay
Transformers - good shots, not too claustrophobic, accessible rules
Honorable mentions: Wheel of Fortune & Monopoly for classic game themes and Shrek/Family Guy for mini-pinball
Bottom 3 (not my cuppa tea even casually):
AC/DC - I liked it a lot at first... but now I really, really, can't stand it. I never want to hear You Shook Me All Night Long again, ever. She built a pin machine, with a lotta bling, it was a big loud thumpin' goofy light machine. Lookin' down at the rules, didn't have no clue, didn't care about what I was supposed to do. Ball is drainin' left, then again on the right, I never kicked a game before but thinkin' I might. And the game keeps blastin', that same old anthem, and I... never want... to... play... this... game... again.
Rolling Stones - Mick... so unfortunate are those screws and so many blocked shots
X-Men - looks more Walmart toy than game or art & dislike plunge-straight-to-drain aspect
Overall, I like Stern games.