Ii think you've already determined this, but when the flipper is stuck up, switch off the game. Does the flipper stay up or fall?
I'm assuming it stays up.
So, open the door, remove the handrail, and slide out the glass, place the glass on something with cushion in a spot not likely to get bumped into.
Back at the game, grab the fat end of the flipper and pull up on it. There should be 1/16-1/8" of up-down motion. If it doesn't move up or down any, that is probably the problem. Lift the playfield, however it is designed and prop it up. Now, while observing the bottom of the flipper assembly, rotate the flipper from above. That should pinpoint the flipper shaft. Whatever mechanism that grabs the flipper shaft needs to be loosened just enough to slide the flipper bat 1/16" up. Then make sure your alignment with the inlane guide top side is good, and retighten the assembly.
The flipper should now be aligned with the inlane guide and have at least 1/16" up/down slop when pulling it up and down.