THE GREAT PRETENDERS:
People love easy, it's human nature.
They want to just go to Home Depot, walk out with a can of clear, go home to their basement, clear a playfield with a brush and put it back in the machine a day or two latter.
As this is the Ultimate playfield restoration guide, were not going to be doing anything like that.
Lets look at some unacceptable products for clearing playfields:
Poly oil.jpg
Pretender #1: Polyurethane
Poly is what people think of when they think "clear protective finish".
This "oil based" clear turns yellow as it ages, even if it claims non-yellowing formula.
Some formulas dry fast, but don't actually get hard for months (even a month latter the "finger nail test" lets you leave a mark).
After a few months of drying, it can be buffed to a medium shine.
Vapors are very toxic.
Do not use Oil Based Poly on a playfield!
--------------------------------------------------------------
polycryl water.jpgW3AS.jpg
Pretender #2: Water Based Poly
This "water based" Poly (sometimes sold as Varathane or Polycrylic), cleans up with water.
The number one reason we don't use it for playfields is that it dulls the colors of the underlying playfield in a serious way. It does not make much sense to do all that work fixing up a playfield, only to dull down the color pallet.
Water Based Poly yellows over time, but not as much as oil-based Poly.
The finish drys very fast, but it takes 3 coats of Water Based Poly to build up the same thickness film of a single coat of Oil Poly. So you need many more coats to get the same protection, but each extra coat is further dulling the colors.
The can says that Water Based Poly is "tougher" than Oil Poly, but on a playfield, ball trails start cutting their way through much more quickly than with Oil .
Water Based Poly can be buffed to a medium gloss, but not as high as other clearcoats.
The vapors give you a headache, but they say it is non-toxic.
Water Based Poly makes a good primer over raw wood if you are going to paint over it, as otherwise the paint may soak into the wood fibers. Because it drys fast, it is ideal for this use.
Do not use Water Based Poly as a clearcoat on a playfield!
Here is a great example from Tdiddy, where the water based poly is peeling away from the substrate. This is not a hard, protective finish, folks:
Tdiddy playfid.jpg
NEVER USE POLY TO 'CLEARCOAT' A PLAYFIELD (p68)
Another well documented Varathane disaster:
https://pinside.com/pinball/forum/topic/rant-the-nightmare-of-cleatcoating-my-gottlieb-hot-shot#post-3936888
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
lacc.jpg
Pretender #3: Lacquer
Lacquer is a fun clear coat for many things because it drys super fast and you don't have to sand between coats.
You don't have to sand between coats because Lacquer is very "hot". It chemically melts into the lower layers, becoming a single layer.
Lacquer can be buffed to a very high gloss.
The bad things about Lacquer are that it turns slightly yellow, it is so hot that it often reacts tragically with other coatings and paints, and it melts decals like nothing else on the planet.
Some older pins were clearcoated with Lacquer.
Vapors are very toxic.
Do not use Lacquer to clearcoat a playfield!
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
1024px-Shellac_varities.png
Pretender #4: Shellac
Shellac is made from the bodies of the Laccifera Lacca insect. It is actually safe to eat, and is used as the coating on Reese's Pieces and fruits like apples.
Shellac has a yellow to amber color to it, and can actually be purchased in different shades.
Shellac flakes are simply dissolved in alcohol and then applied.
Some older pins were actually "clear coated" with Shellac (test under the apron if the finish dissolves with alcohol).
In playfield restoration we use Shellac in layers to match freshly sanded wood to the surrounding wood. Newly sanded wood is bright white, and stands out like a sore thumb. Spraying layers of Shellac allows you to match darker older wood easily.
Vapor are mildly toxic (alcohol).
Shellac is not very durable as a clearcoat, but is does have a place in your tool kit.