I have an 1950’s woodrail that a previous owner replaced the flipper pivot arms with modern style cabinet switches, and it plays f’n sweet… their responsiveness have blown more than a couple minds of guests expecting the classic janky feel of the old arm pivot games.
I contemplated doing it to all my games, but thought better of it after having a wedgehead with perfectly tuned arms that played nearly as responsively. adjusting and tuning the factory arms/mechs is the way to go in order to keep the games original.
If I had a game that no matter how much effort I put in, still wouldn’t tighten up the button/ arm responsiveness, or if they were too mangled/ missing, then I wouldn’t hesitate to throw cabinet switches on.
Aside from a couple screw holes in the cab, it’s reversible if someone else wants to return it to the original arms down the line.