Stern wins the best Mod - hahahaha
I am sure it was a later released withheld feature
You're currently viewing posts by Pinsider swinks.
Click here to go back to viewing the entire thread.
Stern's so called mod was I am sure a with-held game feature later released as the playfield had art to be exposed with the kit - the mod category should be about celebrating what the community creates not the pinball manufacturers.
As for homebrew: I think to be considered it should be:
- flipping
- good set of rules to play a full game,
- art
- sounds
- in a completed cabinet if not it waits to the following year.
Not dishing on Jack Dangers game that won last year as it looks to have a cool layout and the theme sounds real cool but it probably should not have made the voting cut for that year to be up for voting and should not have won - rather be between Spaceballs or Rotodave's Led Zep should of been considered
Also I don't agree with committee members able to fast track a machine / mod into the final category - if it is a vote by the public it should be just that.
voting (resized).pngin regards to a pinball promoter who was part of the committee was able to vote for one of the categories and bring them straight into the final round of voting
as for the homebrew category - it is hard to define but it should be fair to those putting in the hard work creating these masterpieces - it should be at a point where it could go to a show, or play with a few mates and apart from programming tweaks is generally fun and finished - not a game that is still being made - sorry to say but I can't find video of Jack Dangers game from last years win and up to Dec 2019 was still a playfield in design and build progress... which is a kick in the guts to Space Balls and Rotodave's Led Zep
Quoted from rotordave:Honestly ... I could give two shits about these popularity contests, but I’ve been asked many times about this so here’s my bit.
My Led Zeppelin wasn’t even considered for last years “home brew”
I get that mine was more of a retheme, although I added new playfield features etc, it was mostly still a Freedom machine.
As such, maybe a “retheme” category would be appropriate.
There is a lot more work goes into programming a machine from scratch, creating rules etc etc, which is what I’d consider a “home brew” as per the current award.
However - the fact that last year a machine that was no where close to being finished won this category was a real slap to the guys who had spent 100s of hours making *completed” machines. And just showed that the awards are just a popularity contest.
That’s my 10c.
rd
I agree with the slap to the face for others
I approached Jeff a few years ago to have this category added as a recognition for the awesome work done by you and the many others - a retheme is still alot of work as well and at least should of been listed for the public to vote for.
The Sonic win this year is a cool game and good to see the dutch game Haunted Mansion got second. Last years was disappointing.
I have found myself not looking up and listening to the Pinball Network - not intentional just how I like to select just a show on itunes and download to a phone - maybe that is the case with other listeners
Quoted from Wolfmarsh:Fix #1 should still be to stop considering unfinished games.
I like sonic, but the game isn't finished.
totally agree, but it is the screwed up conditions of what qualifies the game into category, like last years results
Quoted from Stebel:Thought what you said about the mod vs planned add on where spot on. WOZ witch was the winner in my book.
totally agree
You're currently viewing posts by Pinsider swinks.
Click here to go back to viewing the entire thread.
Wanna join the discussion? Please sign in to reply to this topic.
Great to see you're enjoying Pinside! Did you know Pinside is able to run without any 3rd-party banners or ads, thanks to the support from our visitors? Please consider a donation to Pinside and get anext to your username to show for it! Or better yet, subscribe to Pinside+!
This page was printed from https://pinside.com/pinball/forum/topic/twipys-are-back-for-a-4th-year-pre-voting-starts-tomorrow?tu=swinks and we tried optimising it for printing. Some page elements may have been deliberately hidden.
Scan the QR code on the left to jump to the URL this document was printed from.