TWD in my opinion. I'm an average player and the first few games on twd were brutal and I initially didn't enjoy it. But it was only one of two games (the other being MM) at the nearby bar/grill when I was at a conference. After about 3 or 4 games I got the hang of it and began to enjoy it just as much as MM. I totally agree that it has less "flow", but interesting layout and makes you want to get further and play longer each time. I've never connected with GOT. For me a game where its all ramp to flipper, ramp to flipper, gets old fast. I like the more unique playfield layouts. Guess I'm more Borg > Ritchie (although enjoy his games, too). Also, the rules matter as well. If you are all about points and multipliers, then GOT. If you are looking for something more unique and immersive, I'd go with twd. My two cents. I don't own either, fyi. But if I did, TWD would be the one. "KARL!!!"