Theatre of Magic.
Great game. Awesome modes. Terrific theme.
The toys and gimmicks are second to none.
It is also rated higher in the pinside top 100. I know there are some that dobt like that as a guideline, but it is compiled by thousands of individual scores...and the masses have spoken.
If we were discussing the TWD premium this would be much tougher (I would still pick ToM, however), but ToM is MUCH better than the pro.