Honestly POTC is actually kind of boring and gets old quick. As it is fairly easy. Specifically if you have a small collection. Mine lasted in my small collection for almost a year then I moved on.

I had the Shadow for about 3 years. And actually miss that the most. And would own another. It's a players game though. Everyone that came over hated it for the fact that it had the 4 buttons for the diverters. So I was the only one who pretty much played it. But I traded that for a XMen LE.
Which is a great game (that you own) shadow is on the same difficulty and fun level as XMen.

I understand the kids being afraid of TWD.
When I had Frankenstein my youngest wouldn't go into the games room. I traded MSF for JM.
Which my girlfriend hated. So that didn't last either.

That's why I'm down to MMr and Totan.
2 games I love. The family loves to play. Friends love to play. Any other games I add now have to be keepers. I only have room for 5-6 so I'm on the fence about most pins.
It has to be real special for me to buy one now.

Hoping for MB remake.
And hoping to find a Scared stiff.
And possibly a Centaur for myself to restore, play and keep. But I know that would be a pin mostly only I would play. And a couple of my pinhead buddies.

If you see TWD as a keeper, keep it. Move it or cover it up.
But if you can see yourself letting it go honestly I would take TS over POTC.
It's a much better game with more to shoot.