That's a tough decision, one that I am currently wrestling with as well. I'm deciding on my second pin and these two are at the top of my list at the moment. I go back and forth, I guess that's why I don't have a second pin as of yet! I like the challenge of TWD, it's a game that feels like it is fighting you, and when you have a good game on it you feel like you've accomplished something special. It can also be insanely frustrating for lesser skilled players. Deadpool is flat out fun. I know a lot of people were disappointed that this wasn't the adult themed DP from the Ryan Reynolds movies, but I think the humor in the game is still true to the character, and the art package is amazing. The modes and quests are fun and unique, and getting the team ups before mode start can really boost scoring. I like that once you play the Sauron mode the next time you play a new villain it actually is different and a little more difficult than the first time. The various multiballs are great (Mechsuit multiball is a blast!), and scoring modes like Katanarama and Berserker are cool too. In the end, for your poll I voted Deadpool, although I think that the overall better game is TWD. I think it fits in better for a family environment, not only because of the theme, but the game is a little more approachable for people of various skill sets