POTC doesnt have the elements for a good long lasting collection game. The rules are way too linear and the game is pretty much limited to 3 shots (Tortuga, kraken, chest). It does however, have very fun multiball scoring and stacking play. It also has a much higher appeal to family and kids than TSPP. So if youre getting a game you could care less about but want to appease family, guests, and kids; then go with POTC. If you're after a pin that will keep your attention over a long lasting time, go TSPP.
(Topic ID: 130765)
Grand Rapids, MI
