I think pinside top 100 is great its not perfect but it does what it needs to do.
And rated by users is fine even if they rate a game on impulse, etc.
If they did nothing I would be fine as I can see the times rated. BUT would be nice if they applied the times rated to the score. It would have to be complex where you do each score level 1-10 and ratings on each, etc, etc... It gets complex but is doable.
Kind of like Airline A has had 3 Accidents and Airline B has had 1.
You would pick B since it had only 1. But if you look at the number B has only 10 flights while A may have had 5000 flights. So which is safer?