As long as you're both happy is what counts. I think they are both in the same ballpark for fun and value. I normally prefer horror themes and have no interest in fishing. But in this case I give the edge to Fish Tales.
Great to see you're enjoying Pinside! Did you know Pinside is able to run thanks to donations from our visitors? Please donate to Pinside, support the site and get anext to your username to show for it! Donate to Pinside