TNA for me and it’s not close. You’re going to spend the same amount of money and get a game that is vastly superior in lighting, sounds, display, and rule set. Not to mention you’ll be supporting an awesome company in Spooky and dude in SD.
The only thing that TNA lacks in is the art dept. (for me) but basically impossible to compete with some of those early SS games. But that’s super low on the priority list for me.