Quoted from Jason_Jehosaphat:Super-bands are murder to get on and, once on, they're hard as rocks. Worst for bounce passing, for sure. Simple rubber is my favorite.
This is totally correct. For my games at home or setting up a game for a tournament, it is pure old fashioned rubber all the way. I would never use anything else unless I was putting a game on route or something.
To me for pure game play and feel rubber is the best, followed by silicone and then a very big gap and poly in last place. Superbands simply play like crap.