I have owned both (no longer do) and have spent extensive time on each table. I would give DH the edge because it's easier to sell (as you can see from the above posts). To say XF is a horrible game though is pretty shallow. There are very few SS games I don't enjoy, I mean after all, c'mon - it is pinball for christ sakes! With that said, and for the record, I would most likely never buy either one again. I got my fill of them for the 3-5 years I owned each and have moved on. Sold the XF for about $1250 less than a year ago (nice with low plays) and the DH about 1-1/2 years ago for $1400 (nice but re-import). Was probably a little under the money on the DH.