I am trying to keep my chin up on this and will give it a fair shake when I play it in person. I am hoping that at least one of the stars of the show steps up and does callouts similar to Carl Urban did in Star Trek. I am a pretty big fan of the show so even if someone like Steven Yeun, Michael Rooker, or David Morrisey would make the game much more appealing.
The music sounds pretty good to me. It has a familiar tone and the main theme music seems integrated well.
The toys seem alright but they could have done a bit more. At least make the zombie head in the barn a vario-target or series of inline drops. Basically, the game seems to have just one bash toy and a stand up target with opening doors in front of it.
The dots? I've expressed it before and its time to move on from the DMD. Not a total deal killer for me, but TWD deserves full color 1080p (queue the "I never look up when playing, lets go back to score reels" people). Even the original House of the Dead arcade game from 1996 has better looking zombie graphics.
Maybe my hopes are too high.