POTC is garbage. I mean the theme is cool, but it is far from exciting.
Sopranos isn't too far behind it...
I feel it's important to designate editions, IF gameplay differs dramatically.
For example, AC/DC pro does not belong on this list, but AC/DC prem/LE certainly does.
I tried to set my personal opinions aside on the list of 10 below and pick the titles with the most longevity in the hobby over the last 1-15 years. I don't even see the point in reviewing or rating a game until it's been out for at least a year. I mean, most game features aren't complete and polished on Stern machines until the first year, sometimes longer.
LOTR (includes "LE" since it's the same gameplay)
SM (includes "black" since it's the same gameplay)
STAR TREK PREM/LE
Iron Man (includes "VE" since it's the same gameplay)
rest of the order:
AC/DC PRO is in here somewhere...
STAR TREK PRO
POTC (I suppose this can be 21st, since everyone has such a hard on for it...)