Love my Shadow. I’ve had it for over 8 years and it’s still a blast to play. Whitewater is a super fun pin too, and is definitely funnier with a better theme.
Layout wise Shadow is the winner. More shots, faster, more brutal. Whitewater is more flowy, but the shots are way more repetitive.
Arts and looks are both good not great.
Shadow has slightly better rules, but Whitwater has soom pretty cool side features too.
Can’t go wrong with either