Quoted from vikingerik:You're in the Rush thread so of course you'll get replies favoring Rush, but I'll actually throw in that even as a Rush owner and fan of the band and not of Foo, I think Foo is the better game. Rush's layout just doesn't quite flow like it should, Foo is smooth as butter. Rush doesn't open up as a game until you get really good to get deep into the time machine upgrades and album combos and wizard modes, Foo is a fun romp no matter what you're doing. The one area Rush does win is portraying the band better with the real concert media rather than the silly cartoon vibe, but Foo is even perfectly pleasant there too.
Both are great pins.....prefer Rush because I worship them musically and I am not at all into the cartoonish nature of ANY pinball machine. Both machines flow wonderfully.....it's a close call. Personal preference of music wins out for me.