For all those saying the theme is great for the audience outside of pinball... WWE isn't just a trailer park thing, "it will do great on location" based on the theme, etc...
The closest example I can think of is NASCAR
- NASCAR has an extremely dedicated fan base (far more than WWE)
- NASCAR has many stereotypes about its fans
- NASCAR is HUGE... HUGE... but it's also very polarizing and doesn't necessarily have BROAD appeal. Size of a market and appeal are not the same thing!
- NASCAR had toys that walk up players could immediately interact with (bash car and ball loop)
- NASCAR is a huge property with massive licensing - but is mainly a domestic product, it doesn't have wide international appeal
I see the WWE licensing as a direct parallel to the above. Large, but polarizing property. Has many stigmas associated with it. Domestic, not global appeal.
Where is location pinball happening these days?
- bars and specialized barcades in urban areas
- specialized pin halls
Who are the audience in these locations? The urban/'burban 20-30 something white collar kids and existing pinheads. Where is the overlap with the classic demographic for WWE? Where is the location overlap for WWE fans and location pin? Pinball is not yet back in the convenience stores or truck stops like it used to be. (not stereotyping.. talking about where you can encounter games vs having to seek them out)
Even with the HUGE dedicated fan base of NASCAR... the license didn't cause the game to break out beyond the game itself.. it didn't break down any barriers... it didn't cause new cross pollination of the demographics.
The same thing happened for the last DE WWF title.. and that came out during a relatively successful period in pin when 'where you found a pinball' was still far more diverse than where you do today.
So what does all this mean? Pinball themes have to appeal to the demographics where you have games and are expanding. Don't look at the market for the brand that has no overlap with the pin market and think they are magically going to converge because of a theme.