From my experience……
Underrated:
Hobbit. Sure it shoots kind of meh and the upper flipper is just really oddly placed and angled. I Think the game was made with other playfield intentions/shots, then they got scrapped, and we get whats left.
Still.....
Awesome game, the ruleset and the immersion is second to none. The wizardmodes, are well… They are simply the best by far.
Overrated:
Monster bash. At first it´s a great game, but differs from great games in that instead of growing with time, it gets smaller and less interesting with time. Still it holds it´s merits in a +5 Collection, since it´s an initial hit and guests and kids will like it.
Not enough to be a top five pin.