* 2. The Hobby CNC Options
Due to my desire to make a custom pinball I wanted to get a hobby sized CNC so I can take control over cutting my own pinball playfield (which I will reference as PF from now on). I could send the work to someone else or do it myself and be able to make as many alterations that I wanted or needed as well as use for many other projects.
So in going this direction I weighed up some things before jumping in:
The positives:
- fairly compact (roughly 1000mm by 1500mm)
- fairly affordable (depends on what you go for)
- fairly user friendly (depends on what option you go for)
- affordable options use belt drives for X & Y axis movement, linear and screw drive is the preferred but there a size limitations and are a lot more expensive
machines can be customisable
- more accurate than cutting by hand and repeatable
- can take the same layout file and use towards the art side of the design
The negatives:
- does take up space if you are space poor
- will cut fairly slowly as basically the router used is a trimmer router
- could require some customisation to get the process area that you want and to make dust pickups but that is half the fun of this project
On doing research (November 2017) of the various machine / company options, I found these 6 to be on my short list:
- X-Carve by Inventables (US)
- Shapeoko 3 by Shapeoko (US)
- Stepcraft 2 - 840 by Stepcraft (German)
- OX CNC - makerstore (Australia)
- OX CNC - ooznest (United Kingdom)
- XYZ-Carve - 3DTek.xyz (Australia)
All the above are kit builds and price is a variable based on the time of research and where it has to come from.
* The X-carve is well known for the great support and awesome community of makers and is apparently a great machine and you can really vary your machine with many options and customise it as you go. You would have to upgrade the machine after purchasing so not a straight out of the box kit build as maximum size is 1000 x 1000mm size not process area.
* The Shapeoko is also well known for great support and great community of makers and apparently a great machine with v3 gaining a lot of improvements / upgrades. You would have to upgrade the machine after purchasing so not a straight out of the box kit build as maximum size similar to the X-Carve and the software looked good as well.
* The Stepcraft 2 is a great bit of machinery and is the step between hobby and commercial with a great design but is not customisable so would not do a PF in one go but allows for feed through work. The company was really good via email which is promising but the CNC programming looked a little over complicated especially for a person with zero experience.
* The OX CNC (Aus Option) is a Openbuild design machine that has been around for a few years and has some solid features with a few design floors as well but a good entry level machine. The company is a little slow on answers at the potential purchase stage. The machine design is customisable and it comes in a kit that can do a PF.
* The OX CNC (UK Option) is also a OpenBuild design machine as above but the companies owner has been proactive in identifying & strengthening up and improving the design in some areas and looks like an impressive upgrade of the Australia version. The owner was great in answering questions and helping out and also could ship parts separately to avoid customs charges.
* The XYZ-Carve is a take on the X-carve adopting a lot of the design and apparently improving the design in places though not staying up to date with some of X-carve’s recent design improvements. The company never replied to some questions on a few occasions and though very affordable and probably the best value for money an option that I struck off due to no communication.