I owned Hobbit, and after a VERY short period, it got old really quick. I've never owned Dialed In, but played it several times on location and think its way way way better. Everyone will talk about how beautiful the Hobbit is, and how good they integrated the video. All of that is true. But the game is basically shooting drop targets and its multiball and pop up monster frenzy and not much else, and that gets REALLY old REALLY fast. I was killing Smaug and getting to all 3 wizard modes almost every game. Just not fun. I wouldn't buy it again unless I got it for like $3k.