Quoted from TigerLaw:With the name Methos I'm guessing we have another TV series in common (Highlander; most under rated TV series of the 90's in my view and Methos was my favorite character).
Yea, I did not follow the Big Finish series and that is why McGann got last place. He was the "reigning doctor" for longer than anyone but other than one audio tape and the fox show I saw nothing of his doctor; so in my mind he is the least developed and gets last by default.
Yea, Perry was ridiculously good looking . . . broke the mold of all things a DW companion should be; LOL.
So, you've seen my list and the directors list . . . what is yours? Share.
First time someone has guessed correctly my name! My wife was a huge Highlander fan when we met - she loved it (the series). I loved the movie because of Connery and the QUEEN soundtrack - so I watched the series with her and Methos was my favorite person from the series. (Mi casa, su casa - or something like that.)
I like Paul McGann to begin with, (W&I, Alien 3, etc), and I loved the way his Doctor looked, dressed, and how he played the part. I thought the last 3 Doctors (Davidson through McCoy) were kind of bland - although Baker suffered from poor production support. So McGann's movie was great in my book. If you get a chance, pick up a few of the BF audios. He's been doing them for years now, and to me, he is the perfect Doctor. Mature, very assured, slightly arrogant but with a great sense of humor and wonderment.
I realize Tennant and Smith have to be all wacky and speak a million miles per second to keep our current ADD crowd entertained, but for once I would kill for some of Pertwee's or Pat's maturity.
And Smith doesn't suck, he's alot better than Tennant in my book who drove me nuts!
My list?
McGann
Pertwee
Troughton
Tom Baker
Eccleson
Smith
C Baker
Davidson
McCoy
Hartnell - too damn old and cranky for me
Tennant
And Peri is STILL beautiful -