Quoted from yancy:One of them is pretty much the consensus greatest game of all time. No one has played a complete version of the other one, and probably won't until about a year after it ships. No offense at all to JJP, but "best ever" vs. "unknown" isn't even a contest.
Yep, I'll take the "unknown" and unplayed Hobbit over MM all day every day, played the supposed "best ever" too many times now and nope, decided to cancel my order so its a no go.
That said, I'm sure Rick will do a great job with the remake.