I'd try to troubleshoot the issue with the ball count unit by starting a 1-player game first. You'll need to check the circuit that sends power to the ball count step up coil (solenoid). Check the following:
Out hole relay switch - green wire and grey/yellow wire
Ball Index relay switch - grey/yellow wire and yellow/red wire
Extra ball relay switch - yellow/red wire and red/yellow wire
Score motor switch A-4 - red/yellow wire and green/orange wire
Coin unit wiper switch position 1 - green/orange wire
Circuit fuse - black/blue wire
Check these switches to make sure they are clean and adjusted properly. Coin unit wiper switch should be centered on the position 1 switch. Check the circuit fuse to make sure it is fully seated in the fuse block; check to see if the fuse is good...