I have a lot of history with both of these titles. The first pin I ever bought was a TFTC. The seller had both a TFTC and a BSD for sale and I had to choose. I took the TFTC, but several years later ended up picking up a BSD. I ended up trading my first TFTC away shortly after that, but picked up *another* TFTC some years later. I ended up selling that TFTC after a few years to fund a NIB purchase, but the BSD remains! I freakin love TFTC, and I would never discourage anyone from picking one up, but it didn't have the staying power of BSD for me or my friends. I found that non-pinheads flocked around the TFTC at major parties, but most of the pinball crowd neglected it. Often it would be the only game not being played when pinheads came over. BSD isn't as deep, but it's also more unique, addictive and imho, easier to maintain. It's the only true horror game B/W ever produced! I guess it depends on what you want out of a game right now.