Personally, I'd go with TAF. It is far more accessible to non-pinheads (important if you have people over frequently) and just a lot more fun to play IMO. I've really tried to learn to like TZ, but still don't care for it much. Not a bad pin, but there are a lot of others I would buy before it.

TZ for sure.

Witchever one you don't pick I might want since we're both in Michigan. Let me know

Tough call. I have and love both. Great themes, both mode based.

TZ was my favorite very early on so I'd probably lean more towards that one personally. The widebody would complement your IJ nicely. Then again, you say the TAF is in slightly better condition...

I think you'll be happy with either one. Or, just bite the bullet and get both!

Yeah, I'd go with TZ too. I own one, so consider the opinion biased, but I've played TAF many times and I just can't seem to get into it. I'd like to own one someday, but I struggle to pull the trigger, and I can't figure out why. I love the Addams Family, so the theme is right. Just doesn't pull me in like TZ does.

Find a way to buy both!

The solution is so simple.

TAF is the greatest creation known to man.

TZ.

Both great games. TZ is deeper. TAF is more fun to just walk up and shoot around on.

TZ for yourself; TAF for the family. But yea, what Gambit said is right on the money about both.

I also own both, and I'd go with Addams. TZ is deeper, for sure, but Addams has a personality.

Both are GREAT games, good luck with your "struggle".

-F

I own TAF and have played alot of games on TZ.
Personal preference I don't think you can go wrong.

Maybe just decide which has the best price for condition or simply which is in the nicer condition.

Wish you the best

ENJOY

TZ is more of a players game and one that ppl love to mod. TAF is fun for everyone. Can't go wrong with either, I own both. Purchase both pins and then sell the one you like the least.

TZ is a chore to play unless you're playing well. TAF puts a smile on my face regardless of how i play. i vote taf.

Have both. TAF has a wider audience at our house, but both are equally awesome games. You won't go wrong with either one. Enjoy!

Brian

Since you are looking for opinions.... TZ X 10! I cannot get into TAF for some reason (and played it tonite!). I own and love TZ. It is so strategic with lots of things to get obsessed with (I love the Dead End, Power Field and Gum Ball). Sorry to TAF lovers, but no contest for me.... (I actually want to love TAF, but don't yet...)

TZ by a mile (and I own both games FWIW).

I own both and TAF is my strong preference. My TZ might be going up for sale soon too.

TZ is deep with cool toys. Newbies don't play it and while I respect the hell out of the design, toys and tie into theme - I struggle to really enjoy it for a long time. TAF is a keeper for me. Game everyone will walk up an play, layout is cool, one of the best multiball sequences, another strong theme tie in, and blast to play.

Either one can't go wrong.

I owned both, then sold my entire collection. When I got back into pins, TZ was at the top of my must have list and currently own it. I don't have enough interest in TAF to buy it back again. So, obviously, I strongly prefer TZ.

I own both. I would definitely go with TZ over TAF. TAF is more fun and has more personality but not nearly as deep and I can see myself getting bored of it already... I have only had it a couple of months now. I have had TZ for 12 years and I still enjoy playing it.

Which theme do you like more? I would pick that one. Both are great games which are easy to find

My wife and I owned both. We sold TZ and still have TAF. For us, TZ was sort of a chore to play, probably because of our skill level more than anything else. TAF seems more exciting / flashy to us and we found ourselves playing TAF much more than TZ. With that said, it all comes down to personal preference. Think about what draws you to the pin the most...the play, the sound effects, the artwork, the theme...then when you can't decide, do what comes naturally --- buy both!

Like most here I have both. I would suggest TAF to start off your collection. TZ is just a more complex game (both from a mechanical and a rule-set point of view). I also think the TAF theme is more coherent and approachable. TZ can appear a bit fragmented and hard to follow if your not used to the game.
On the other hand, I think TAF will always be easier to find than a TZ so, if you get the chance at a decent TZ for a fair price, snap it up while you can. TAF was the most produced game in history and you should not have any issue getting one later. You must be a Pat Lawlor fan!

I struggled with the same decision in 1997 and ended up with the TZ. The complexity and deep rule set kept me happy for a very long time. I bought a TAF a few weeks ago so I finally have both. I'm glad I went with the TZ first.

tz my first game and does continue to hold my interest, for smaller collection better game, maybe not 1st game people walk up to , but if you're more concerned about how it holds up for you tz

TAF - Had both, TZ was not nearly as much fun especialy when people are over and want to play a few games - The crowd gets bored quick - TAF on the other hand all I can say is "IT's Show Time!"

I have to concur, TAF is a true crowd pleaser, TZ is totally awesome, but seems to appeal to advanced players more then casual players. TAF will get the heck played out of it where TZ will get moderate play. I have had both, TAF remains. Both excellent PLaw games, cannot really go wrong either way.

TZ is a players game, rule sets, shot selection, stacking, modes, tons of toys.

TAF is a fun all around game and is more approachable for non pin heads.

Both great games!

Tons of mods for both games if you like that stuff.

Same designer

Can't go wrong with either one.

Both awsome games, but TZ is one of a kind!!!

Good news is either one you will be able to trade or sell quickly if you so desired. I personally like TZ better.

i haven't come to that same conclusion.

TZ is a great pin, but I think TAF would suit you better.

They both sell pretty quickly in my area if fairly priced.

Chop chop quick round here.

You meant to say the most overrated pin known to man, right?

TZ in a landslide.

While I agree with this statement,

TAF has the instant fun factor, TZ is a thinking game. I personally like TZ more then TAF, but TAF has curb appeal and is a blast to play, even if you are not that good, but still manages to present a challenge to more advanced players too. It appeals to a wider audience with a well executed, very popular theme. It gets you excited and energized by the plot unraveling quickly. It gets played, a lot.

Sorry, dude, i was talking about the trade aspect and not selling. I wasn't arguing the sell if priced right part. I abide.

you choose wisely... congrats on the tron, also! Great game, would be ranked higher if b/w made it (i think).