Hobbit gets my vote!…I had a TAF on loan from a friend and after playing it for a few weeks it just got boring. It felt like the only shots that were important on the pin was the ramp and scoop. I have owned my Hobbit for a few years and it’s still in my lineup and every time I start to think it’s time to sell Hobbit I play a few games and I just can’t do it…I can see why lots of people have bad opinions on The Hobbit(especially if they played it on location or a pin show) because I played one at a show and walked away thinking if I played this before I bought my Hobbit I would’ve passed on it. Hobbit needs to be set up properly and played in a home to truly enjoy and experience all it has to offer. One last thing to keep in mind is that The Hobbit will require you to pay attention to the main LCD screen and the mini LCD to help you on your adventure. Maybe that’s why a lot of people can’t enjoy Hobbit but really like TAF due to TAF’s simple gameplay.