I know this is a different kind of heresy, but I wanted some of that same “spooky” effect and decided to try replacing some of the back GI bulbs in my TAF with purple LEDs. It really worked out well! The area is lit up enough but the throw of the purple bulbs is different and enhanced the artwork in a way I was really happy with. You may consider that too. I prefer not to use incandescents due to the additional power draw and to minimise maintenance, but sometimes you just gotta do it...
One other thing you can try is buying a GIOCD from Herg. You can dial down the brightness of your GI lights, and this may have the same effect. In addition, “showtime!” multiball looks INCREDIBLE, the way the GI dims properly, with no flicker as was intended all along