I owned a gorgeous HUO POTC a few years ago, and I own a SW Premium now. POTC is highly underrated IMO, but I'd still give Star Wars the nod. It's a flow monster and a total rush, plus it's got a great light show, outstanding sound/music, video clips, and code that will only get better (and the code is already pretty darn good as-is).
No matter which game you pick, you win. It's a good dilemma to have...