Ratings are all subjective and personal opinions. No need to get hung up on them. Yes it's ridiculous that a brand new pin has such a high ranking. SW is fun to me because it's Pinball but it's not a great game. Everyone has different tastes. For example I think Kiss is a hell of a game and very under rated.....many can't stand it and I could care less. Rankings are meant to be fun. Water finds its level and if enough honest rankings are submitted it will balance out. In 20 years let's see what games are in the top 20. The reality is very few new features have been added to pins.....that's helped some of these older games stay in the top 10-20 lists. Until new gameplay innovations happen I don't see the top 10-20 games changing too much.