Quoted from practicalsteve:
I want to add that looking at the switch with the problem it looked perfectly adjusted. I never would have realized it needed cleaning and adjusting without using the schematic and the jumper.
sadly, this will not be the only time that this happens...
the dreaded "switch that looks like it is making when it really isn't" glitch...
but now you know how to read the schematic, and how to isolate "breaks" in circuits... a good learning day!