I prefer Super Bands as they have an excellent track record of proven durability.
They have a similar play to "red" rubber but do seem to have a bit more gription to them which I don't mind one bit. Guess that I am used to them.
They really do clean easily and wear,,,,,well, I haven't worn any out. But have played many routed games that are wearing well.
Truth be told, I haven't yet tried Perfect Play.