Do any of these products shed less dust into the machine through normal use?

I have a NIB Game of Thrones Pro with the standard black rubbers, and just cleaned it for the first time. Black rubber dust was everywhere.

So I am wondering, do any of these replacement products do better? I'd like the feel as close to real rubber as possible (all this talk of Superbands making the game too easy scared me off), and I'm fine sticking with the original black color too. I want to increase the life of the machine by decreasing the amount of dust.

Would a set of Titan Competitions in black do the trick? Or do they all shed particles?

Thanks!