I’m having these same symptoms. It looks like my switch may have been replaced at some point and has a shorter actuator arm than shown above.
Does anyone sell a switch with the XL actuator arm?
29292D61-2B75-4B2D-AB91-88A6B5EA9360 (resized).jpeg928E1F39-EEC5-4E11-A9EC-9AB7706E92C4 (resized).jpegFF854CFE-FCA5-49A3-9CF8-A8DAFA0D512B (resized).jpeg