Quoted from Lermods:This is an amusing thread, as if this never happened before. I could substitute XM and TAV every time ST is mentioned, exact same experience.
I can't agree with this at all. They're entirely different experiences.
TAV - released with nearly completed code which really hasn't changed much. The rules are actually very good and I think the game is decent. All my issues with avengers are related to the layout. I think the code knocked it out of the ball park. Tons of strategy, great stacking, great sound and lighting effects. Lonnie's best game for sure. A couple bugs and missing dots on wizard mode (which I've never seen) but for the most part this game code wise is a win.
Xmen - this had to be the worst code ever released on a pinball game when it came out. And the year long journey after that was horrible. But all that aside, the game in its current state is fantastic. The current code is not just good, it's great. There are also a couple small issues in how wizard mode wraps up. I am staying on v1.5 rather than v1.51 due to this but really, the rules are awesome. I don't think xmen wil ever recover from its journey and reputation that got it to where it's at now. But the package as it stands today is great. Layout has a ton of stuff going on, game features are all integrated and used well. And the rules are well integrated.
Compare this to Star Trek. It's first release wasn't as bad as say xmen. And the game as it stands has ok rules. The game is fun. Unfortunately, the code is just missing something that makes for exciting pinball. I'm not great a figuring out why it's not great. I think I might want to rewrite these rules as a fun hobby project if it doesn't get sorted out. I think the layout is one of the smoothest playing funniest layouts and the theme is a winner for me.