I have now played both GNR (LE) and Led Zeppelin (Pro) and here are my thoughts:
First, as it turns out, comparing these two games, although inevitable, is dumb. They couldn't be more different in style and other than both featuring a band theme, have nothing in common.
-
GNR is a packed playfield that is heavy in multi-ball modes and prominently features a center scoop as well as upper playfields.
LZ is an open playfield that features long shots into ramps and orbits.
-
GNR has a lot of action with song segments and an adventure-style code where you try to complete songs.
LZ is more laid-back and plays entire songs with a code that is more about hitting shots than advancing a "story."
-
GNR is packed with things to look at on the playfield (hat, cymbals, guitar head stocks, drum sticks, tons of lighting inserts).
ZL is sparse with relatively few lighting inserts, nothing on the playfield other than a non-interactive zeppelin and a jumping Icarus.
-
GNR is a spam the flipper-type game and hope the balls don't drain with long ball times when you do hit ramps and orbits in those rare cases when your ball isn't in the center plunge.
LZ is a flow-game with long shots primarily into ramps and orbits with quick returns.
-
GNR has two video displays (including the main video display that is much larger than LZ) that have a lot of advanced graphics (gun animations, etc.) and add to the gameplay experience.
LZ has one video display that primarily plays hard to see concert scenes and has relatively basic graphics and animations.
-
GNR has the worst plunge in all of pinball.
LZ has the second worst plunge in all of pinball.
-
GNR (LE) costs $3,300 more than LZ (Pro).
-
I like both games, but I think GNR looks like a much more expensive (which it is) and impressive pin, whereas LZ plays a lot better if you like hitting long satisfying shots. I would truly be surprised if any buyer would regret going with one over the other because they are so different they really shouldn't appeal to the same buyer.
For me, I'd rather own GNR, but I'd rather play LZ.