What the "HECK" are you talking about?
It is so empty and bare-without actually flipping it makes it sound like you are an armchair quarterback sitting back in your LAZY-Boy like your Avatar.
The "ART" is "ug"- you as a designer should know about what assets are available for certain licenses and how difficult things can be to get signed off on for "creative art". and yes the albums are great for "Fans".
"GNR" is an execution of a fantastic repetitive light show-it will really wow the newbie players for years to come!
Yes 007(Live and let Die) is a fantastic "copied" song best performed by Paul and probably is the best part of the entire game
I do agree with your comments about it playing like Guitar Hero(actually a great analogy) It does just that-shoot for the next blinking light in sequence for song, now do that 20+ times in a row-again repetitive to many.
I also agree with your saying it is weird. To me it just feels off and does play weird-(great light show though).
I value your opinion as a designer and can say when America's Most Haunted was released, I shrugged it off and thought it was a turd. You know what happened next? I actually played it and I ended up loving it! Do not judge a book by it's cover