I have mixed feelings about buying pins for others vs. myself. I buy pins that are only super kid friendly in theme.
I've had a Beatles and loved it, if I had a bigger collection (5-ish pins, I might pick one up again). That is a simple ruleset for people to follow.
OP, have you thought about an Iron Man? Bash toy, ramps, fun game.
I had a JP LE at my house for about 4 months, it got old how difficult it was. I realized I was not a good enough player at the time to really make progress in the game. I would have it again someday, but for me, I was ready to let it go. (It was a loaner I was shopping out for a friend)
One of the reasons we have multiple games is because some are easy, some are difficult. We aren't all the same skill level and all have different moods. I don't think there is one perfect game for everyone.
Rush Prem is the newest game in my home and I love the flow. The kiddos like it too. BM 66 is one that people gravitate towards with the moving crane. It is also a killer game.
With that being said, if you have spent time on JP and love it, get it. There is enough at the beginning of the game that a casual will have fun with and enough in it to keep you busy for years to come.
Let us know what you decide.