Sorry Bud, you don’t get it.
I think we would all agree with the fact that every new game is shiny and that new owners nearly always get caught up in the novelty and overhype a game. No argument there.
But Godzilla is not like other games. There’s a reason it’s holding steady at number 1 and has been since release.
I’m not saying that it’s the best game ever. (My own opinion is that it’s at least one of the best games ever, though)
But give it proper recognition that it’s not just another over hyped new release.

Curious though: what did you think when you played it? It seems to leave a pretty good first impression on most people.

MM was released right before pinball lost favour with the masses. It’s a fantastic game of course, but it was also undeniably “tops” for the next number of years (decade? More than?) while pinball companies were cutting costs to survive. So it rightfully amassed thousands of “best game ever” ratings over time.
There’s so much competition now for any new release that it’s pretty crazy to have anything knock it from its perch.
Especially when you have some people who will throw it a “1” just to tumble the numbers.
I personally don’t think I could ever pick a single game as best ever because no matter the game, I need some variety after awhile. But I do think that Godzilla might be the current MM.

I wouldn't call him a troll. I'd just say he's a few node boards short of a fun game.