Quoted from BrokenChair:I think Elwin is a great addition to stern but to me it appears his Ego needs a little bit of a check(from how he holds himself) cause I’m not a fan of his attitude from some interviews
I believe he just got real lucky with the initial success of Godzilla ;
but I feels over time the game will settle to its rightful place. But he seems a wee bit eh from what I’ve heard of him.
It doesn’t help that all the people that interview are fan boys that don’t help his ego in the right way…. Just treat the guy like a normal guy .
It's absolutely fine to like any game more than another but to insert a judgement about the designer into that seems at best a bit misguided and at worst, well, pretty jerky. I've listened to many interviews of him, and I've never had any thought that he comes across as having a big ego. My impression has been quite the opposite. I've always thought he comes across as a down to earth guy who really likes pinball...
...And, um, luck has nothing to do with it. He's at minimum one of the best pinball players ever (most think he's THE best) and he's been playing for a very long time. So maybe it's worth it for you to consider the possibility that he does know more than most people about the game of pinball and how to design a machine that players really like. It's a thing called talent. He's also designed not just Godzilla, but three other really, really good games (and maybe 4 with the 60th Bond TBD) and his first one was started as a home brew so, again, it's not luck.
Why do people (including me), think Godzilla is such a great game?
1) Approachable yet challenging layout with interesting shots and mechs.
2) A deep and wide rule set that makes you use all the shots in the layout, and which is very well balanced in scoring so the game can be attacked from many different ways without having much of an "everyone just does this when they play it" strategy.
3) Fun and creative wizard modes.
4) A video, audio, and callout package that puts it all together in a very entertaining way.
In other words, the game is really good in all the key elements of what makes a modern pinball machine fun.