Quoted from Dr-Willy:

The problem is the echo chamber for hate/complaining is much bigger then the praise one. IMO its not because of the number of people on either side, people just like to complain more then praise about stuff. If you receive really good service somewhere how likely are you to go write a review of a place on yelp, facebook, ect, ect vs if you received really really bad service?
I see the same people crap in every thread relating to a game that they don't like (this isn't just SW related), however I see many different people say good things about a game, however they don't post in every single thread related to the game. They normally post it once and be done with it, so it becomes much harder to get an honest number of people happy vs unhappy.

Quoted from Chisox:

I have no idea what this means but I laughed my ass off when reading it.

Quoted from megadeth2600:

There's absolutely nothing wrong with Star Wars' gameplay. It's a frigging great game. The pro model is worth every penny ... especially if you're routing it. Most of the issues are with the pricetag and features when you're paying premium and LE money. That's where Star Wars is falling short (in my opinion).
I wouldn't call either game a swing and a miss ... they're both great ... especially if you are a Ritchie or Lawlor fan ... each game instantly reminds you of what you love about their designs .

Quoted from beelzeboob:

Guess you didn't see the DI reveal at Expo. It's amazing how quickly opinions change around here in a year. GOT was creamed by people here on the reveal. Now it's considered a great game by many of the top players.
Let's all just take a Xanax and see how the game develops. As for me, I'm staying in on my LE order, regardless of everybody else's opinion.

Quoted from Spankey:

While I am a big fan of DI, I don't think SW is a total dog. That said, my problem with it is more about what wasn't or could have been done with the theme than what was. From the lunch box art work to the empty playfield, there seems to be very little pride and effort put forth to elevate the game given the theme.
I'm a huge Star Wars fan as any but I don't just lap up every product tied into the movies. Such a missed opportunity for greatness.

Quoted from beelzeboob:

The Star Wars reveal was about as bad as it gets as well. Yes, it's undercooked. But what's missing? Just a bunch of toys that modders like me can put in there to spice it up. (EDIT: And some playfield magnets, I'll give you that.)Take all the toys out of LOTR and what do you have? You still have a great game. You can order all the flashy shit from Amazon, throw some LEDs in the toys, and BAM! you have a packed playfield. (Many mod companies are already working on this, btw.)
Fun is the primary concern for me with any game, and when I had the chance to play the game with the volume jacked in a quiet room, it was a friggin' blast. People should stop focusing on what their expectations were and look at the fun game we got, which will only get better with code updates.

Quoted from beelzeboob:

The Star Wars reveal was about as bad as it gets as well. Yes, it's undercooked. But what's missing?

Quoted from beelzeboob:

Well, to be fair, the premium/LE has four magnets in the hyperspace loop and a jump ramp (a kind of diverter)...and the shooter lane gate which also fits the definition of a diverter. If the death star explosion is done well, that'll be a pretty cool toy as well. When you think of a game like Tron, that's a pretty open playfield with only one feature: the spinning disc behind the motorized drop target bank. But that game is still awesome as well.

Quoted from eggbert52:

Here would be my negative review.
Review: The game sucks.

Quoted from Schusler:

All of the "what should I buy???' posts - be gone!

Quoted from dnapac:

Respect you totally...but Star Wars, for me, is adrenaline...I think Stern got this right. I will admit that I haven't played it yet, but have a premium coming. TSPP is a blast to play, and someday I hope to own one, but Star Wars for me is not slow, and strategic, it's balls-to-the-walls! "You're all clear kid. Now let's blow this thing and go home." BOOM!!!