I think Creesphow would be AMAZING - I'm due to get an Alice Cooper any day now, and the comic book animations are giving off a bit of a Creepshow vibe. You already have 8 modes ready to go out of the gate (each story from 1 &2), the artwork could mimic the comic book intermissions, you have the story narrator to make callouts etc, it's absolutely perfect for pinball!
I didn't think I would have another dream movie theme outside of Halloween, Alien, BTTF, Ghostbusters and Jaws - but I think this one would definitely make the cut!
Come on Spooky - "Where's my caaake"!