Quoted from Budman:Space Station or Space Shuttle...... Convince me that Station is the better choice.
Kris
"Better" is subjective, so what do you consider "better"?
Gameplay on both can be fast, with simple objectives yet unforgiving aspects.
Station is the official sequel to Shuttle. It borrows concepts like the a 3-drop target bank strafing a lane, "stop & score" ramp guarded by a single drop, and prominent bonus scoring grid. But Station's are more difficult than Shuttle's.
Station has an amazing amount of features / mechs / tech packed into it, and is intricate to look at. Shuttle is almost elegant in its simplicity. Station is System 11b so parts/service are easy to come by. Shuttle is System9 which is rarer and perhaps a bit more fragile.
Station has objectively superior sound, music, and vocals, as well as animated alpha displays and incredible light shows. Shuttle's sound palette works but its sound/display profile is more similar to early 80's games like Firepower.
Gameplay-wise, Shuttle is easily understood and definitely has that one-more-go aspect to it, so newcomers seem to grasp it easily and stick around. You can have a 10-minute monster game followed up by a 10-second ass-kicking. Station is more complex, and unlike Shuttle the mini-pf and diverter shots can seem to interrupt speed and flow a little bit. It requires a slightly different style of play owing to its lack of inlanes, which tends to put people in a love or hate camp. Neither game has a very deep ruleset and both well predate the "mode era", so you're relying on skill to keep working up multpliers and cashing out multiballs when the time comes.
Historically, Shuttle was the game that saved pinball in the 80's and for good reason. Station's lack of inlanes, bonus round, bi-level lane change, and color-change GI are fairly unique in pinball. Seems like they threw everything at it, not sure why it didn't quite catch.
Over 7,000 Shuttles were made. A little over half that many Stations were built. A lot of Shuttles were beat to hell but CPR made reproductions in recent years so nice ones are out there. Station had factory mylar which preserved them much better, generally. That said, the pricing is closer than one might guess but Station should and usually does cost more. OTOH I haven't priced any Shuttles lately, seems they may have increased in price since I got mine. Apparently I got a good deal on my Station as well, so who knows.
Personally, owning both, it would be hard to choose just one. Nice thing is you can get both for the price of a many single "B" list games.