I am in the process of acquiring components to put a LCD in my POTC. Here's my take on it from the reading I have done. The LCD draws enough current that it doesn't seem wise to draw off the games 12v. So, if you're going to have 1 wall wart for the LCD, you might as well power the Pi with a 2nd wall wart. Here is the single, most usefull post I have read in making sense of this whole thing.
https://pinside.com/pinball/forum/topic/smartdmd-color-display-setup-guide
BTW, I once had a DE Batman power supply board go up in smoke with no mods on the game at all. Burnt a hole right through the board.